Just One Thing to Say
At the James River Writers Conference this year, Robert Goolrick (and I had a totally fangirl reaction to him! What a writer!) said most writers have just one or two things to say. That's it. And they spend their lives trying to say that ONE thing, better and better (hopefully) with each book.
I tend to think he's right.
I do not consider myself an optimist . . . but I consider myself a very content, happy person. In fact, I am the LEAST likely person to ever be depressed mainly because I tend to face whatever difficulties life hands me with a "put on your big girl panties and deal with it" or "it is what it is." YET, when I think about the ONE recurring theme in nearly EVERY book (even all my comedies) . . . it's grief. I find the human condition--the idea that we are born alone and die alone, that we say goodbye to so many people we love along the way--to be fascinating. And nearly every character I write is processing some major loss, trying to figure it out, put it on a shelf where it won't consume them, put on a braver face and go out and live.
Ultimately, I think my characters are trying to make SENSE of things that make no sense. And the resolution of that is acceptance. It's the same lesson I learn. And re-learn.
And re-learn.
It's funny, but I rarely, if ever, feel sorry for myself for being sick--not even when in the hospital for extended stays. It doesn't tug at me. I have Crohn's disease . . . because. People get sick and die . . . because. It isn't FAIR but life isn't. So it is what it is.
I find I waste MORE time trying to understand PEOPLE. Wondering at someone's seeming lack of conscience. The Penn State case, for example, is the type of thing on the news that TUGS at me. It nags at the edges of my consciousness. I find myself really thinking about it. I ask, Why? Or maybe more . . . HOW? How can people do such dark and awful things? The last couple of years, I have seen, as I've said before on this blog, Grownups Behaving Badly. People I thought I knew. Once I realized there was no solace to be found in trying to understand others, I turned the focus to me. How could I have been so betrayed or fooled by other people? Is it because I DON'T act that way--so I don't expect it in others? I'm not naive--so you'd think a grown woman would learn. But then . . . it goes back to never understanding the HOW.
And so it goes back to the writing. Characters trying to make sense of that which . . . never will make sense. And so then it becomes finding a sense of peace. A way to live WITH that which makes no sense. A way to live WITH grief and not have it overtake their lives.
In Illuminated (brief shameless plug: preorder it!) . . . Callie wishes she knew her mother, long dead. But her mother is unknowable. How can you know someone who never lived long enough to be there for you? And yet . . . I think part of the journey of my heroine is that at some point Callie finds the traits of her mother are part of her. To know her mother, she only has to look in the mirror. And that makes the grief . . . more manageable.
Do you have just ONE thing to say? And if so . . . what is it????

32 comments:
A agree also. I think perhaps I'm just now realizing it but regardless of genre I think all my writing is somehow about my poor relationship with my father which has made me a romantic at heart with a steadfast belief that love conquers all so when you find your true love you gotta hold on for all it's worth. Or something like that. hell I don't know but I bet a psychiatrist could have fun with me.
I totally agree with that assessment. It also applies to readers...we gravitate toward writers whose thematic message speaks to us. The old Dean Koontz reader (order trumps chaos) vs. Stephen King reader (It's a free-for-all bloodbath because there IS no order) debate.
Religion/God seeking shows up in almost everything I write. It isn't the point, the moral, the whatever, but I've come to recognize it as a fingerprint on my work even though I didn't set out to do that. It took hundreds of thousands of words for me to even realize that the pattern was there. Other readers might not see it because only one of my WiPs has explicit discussion of religion.
I think it's part of my ongoing struggle with the concept of faith and the frustration of believing something you can't know or prove. There is always fear: fear that I'm wrong and there is nothing, fear that I am right, in which case I'm a failure. I guess it takes up such a big part of my subconscious that it bleeds into everything else.
Travis:
We used to joke that this blog was like lying on a shrink's couch. Get comfy. ;-)
Laurel:
Freudian Slip was a whole seeking novel, but I do know there have been spots of it in mine--in Double Down, I think the heroine is searching for a morality in an almost religious sense. But I think it mine, it's still spinning around trying to understand and make sense of that which makes no sense. Which of course makes no sense. ;-)
I suspect it's true of me, although I'm not entirely sure what that one (or two) things is. I know one theme throughout my books has to do with fathers and sons, explorations of those relationships to some extent. It crops up so much it must be there.
As for other things, I'm sure it's there, but I'm not exactly sure what it is. Maybe it's doing the thing that needs to be done because you think it needs to be done, regardless of the consequences, good or bad. Maybe some undergrad English students could tell me.
Mark:
I think Derek is definitely that guy who does it because . . . well, he's the guy. It's easy to think that themes aren't there in a thriller that goes at breakneck speed, but in the characters--the best of them anyway--are those ideas that tug at us.
If I was a shrink I'd have a leather couch and then ask the vegans how that made them feel while they were laying on it. But I'm cruel like that.
I'm constantly seeking family. My characters build families the way other people build with legos, one person at a time. I even have a character who collects misfits. My fictional families are uncomfortable and extended and messy.
Oddly, in RL I have this perfect (ha! on paper maybe!) little nuclear family.
I like Laurel's comment (but don't tell her). I know the limb creaks when I say this, but I think every writer, every artist, every composer, every scientist, every thinker is on a quest to discover God.
I think that so many of my ideas stem from that old time saying.
Shit happens.
The fight starts the day we are born and continues past our death. No one person's battle is more or less than the next. Life is a war dance that we learn and perform. Sometimes we win, and sometimes we lose. But most importantly overall, is that we never stop.
Travis:
You are a sick, sick man. ;-)
Starbucks:
My extended family of friends is a motley assortment. My nuclear family is pretty eccentric. I always have both in my books.
Stephen:
I wonder. My dad is an avowed atheist, but I know he ponders it. Not that it makes him agnostic. But he does puzzle over the question from time to time.
Stephen:
And as a P.S. I wonder if that search is because no one know what happens after death, and all living people, most of them anyway, struggle to reconcile life with knowing it comes to an end.
JOHNNY!!!!!!!!!!!
Thanks for dropping by in the midst of I am sure school insanity. :-)
I love the way you put it.
xo
"I find the human condition--the idea that we are born alone and die alone, that we say goodbye to so many people we love along the way--to be fascinating."
To me, the very best of your books that I've read so far (The Roofer) truly has that theme.
I'm looking forward to reading Illuminated.
Joe:
Constructing that book around an Irish wake and funeral and all of the intricacies of a family in mourning made that exploration at the forefront. Maybe that's why it's my favorite book, too, of mine. That an Invisible Girl.
Definitely. I keep writing about characters - both male and female - who didn't know their biological father growing up and how they're stuck in their life until they come to terms with that.
Interesting post, Erica!
kathy:
Interesting! And I wonder for how many of us do these things we seek to write about . . . mirror real life in some way. I know my inherent "one thing" is one thing that I ponder in real life as well.
Kathy and Erica: I think that is TRUTH. Recurring themes often reflect conflict resolution for the author. It sounds trivial or dismissive to say this, but it's very close to the child psychiatrist saying "Show me on this doll what happened to you."
It is the distance of fiction that gives us the freedom to explore other possible outcomes or even other possible causes and imagine solutions.
You know my thoughts about this subject and I’m so glad you brought it forward in your blog. It’s been so interesting to read everyone’s comments. It was so great to sit in on his interview and so eye opening. Now I don’t have the benefit of collectively adding up all of my work, mostly because I do not have a lot. But, if I look at what I’m writing currently (novel) and some short stories and poems that I’ve already written and what I plan to work on next, then yes I believe what he says is true. For me, it’s about survivorship and finding truth.
Perhaps we (as writers) are brave soldiers. We fight hard on the battlefield of paper. I have found that my thoughts are not so unique. That many people are seeking what I’m seeking. Simply put…….clarity. On whatever subject pulls on our souls and in the hopes that somewhere, somehow we touch someone else’s life, as we touch our own. Because to communicate, whether in conversation one on one or in written word to the unknown, we all share in one simplicity….we all want to be loved, to experience love and to give love. However we define it…. is our own unique way. And just as no two snowflakes are alike, neither is our written word. Each of us brings it differently and in the end that’s a good thing.
Lisa:
It was a great interview to sit in on, and that resonated with me, as you know.
Clarity. Yes, that's it. And I've learned that when people aren't clarity-seekers, I have very little in common with them. It's taken me that last couple of years to learn that those are the people that, for me, I need to walk away from. And go find the people who are seekers.
Erica, I've missed you! I've been horrid about checking my reader.
I love how you describe you/your characters quest to make sense of things that do not make sense. This is a very good "one thing." :)
I think my "one thing" would be that you can love people who are very different from you, even if you see them as "other," if you are brave enough question your own assumptions.
JA:
Love that, too!
I am SO far behind on my blog reading. At least you can be happy yours is the first blog I went to when a free moment appeared.
This is such an interesting topic. I think my one thing would be rising above those who would destroy you to become so much more than how others have defined you during your life. Often that takes place within a failing mother/daughter relationship.
Beth:
I AM honored! :-)
xoxox
Just one thing to say... you are stronger and wiser than I.
Just one thing to say... you are stronger and wiser than I.
Erica, are you OK?
FF, you might want to friend her on Facebook. She posts frequently there. I tried to email you back but I got a failure to deliver notice.
I don't have a Facebook account. I was worried, but now that you have told me that she posts frequently chez Facebook, it is okay. Thanks, Jude.
Bless you meant for ad this, It's basically exactly what When i was searching for concerning google. I'd loads fairly find out beliefs at a man, just a little as opposed to a business internet page, that's exactly why I really like websites which means noticeably. Cheers!
Adelina
Via : Strep Throat Symptoms
Post a Comment