Seeking the Truth
The man lied.

I am not sure at what point someone crosses over from "someone who lies" to "liar." I actually looked up the definition of "liar" on Webster's while sitting here, and the dictionary is pretty clear-cut: "someone who lies."
But I think if we each search ourselves, we all occasionally lie. White lies. Maybe we're put on the spot. Liars, in our lexicon, tend to be the ones we think tell the insidious lies. Or they lie all the time. They lie to hurt. They lie for self-preservation despite knowing they hurt.
In the time I knew this man, he lied. More than once. With devastating results.
But out of those events, there are two truths.
There is the "truth." If you had put a tape recorder in the room on that day, there was what he said on tape. How do I know I didn't misunderstand? Or maybe misinterpret? Aside from an aural photographic memory--ask anyone, have always had it--what he said was SO chilling that my teeth chattered. It hung in the room, and I thought the temperature dropped a few degrees. I knew that what he said was going to hurt someone (another person) deeply. There was no mistake. But then he walked out of that room, and went to a meeting two days later and denied--outright--that he said what he did. And the fallout from that lie, like toxic dominoes falling down, resounded through quite a few lives, including my own. So there was "truth." What was said.
But then, there was Truth. The search to make sense of the aftermath.
Truth--with a capital T--is a winding journey. It's ongoing, in every single aspect of my life. It isn't confined to that event, or one event, but to all events. My blog, actually, has been a mult-year, nearly 1,500-post (holy CRAP, have I really posted that many times?) search for my own Truth. In fact, over the last couple of years, a few times I have had people challenge my Truth, try to take it away from me. Perhaps it would be more convenient if I didn't say what I did on this blog or in life. Or maybe I should view things differently--whatever it is. But the thing about Truth is it's your own.
And mine is utterly unwavering. A gift of growing older, I sometimes think, though age is no guarantee of knowing the Truth.
Which is not to say someone cannot change my mind. No, that's being close-minded. I will try to listen to others' perspectives. Sometimes if only to try to understand how the heck it is they can believe what they do. Or, as a novelist, to try to understand motivation. I have often asked myself how certain people can look at themselves in the mirror. I don't know. And so I do study people. All the time. Occupational hazard.
It's also not to say the man who lied didn't have his own Truth. That lying was a faster way to accomplish what he felt needed to be done. Or maybe he hated women. Or maybe just me. Just because we might not like someone else's Truth doesn't mean it's not theirs.
For Truth is the bedrock of who you are. For me, it is absolutely a commitment to be kind. It is a sureness in the fact that my children are the center of my Universe. It is knowing what I value. Knowing who I love.
I often quote a scene in the movie Adaptation, in which one brother cannot understand how his sibling told a woman he loved her when he knew damn well she didn't love him back.:
You are what you love, not what loves you, I decided that a long time ago.
I know what I love. That is my Truth and always will be.
And that is what I hope to teach my children. Peers are so influential, but deep, deep inside you know the Truth. You know right from wrong. You know it. So hold tight to it.
You can't control the world around you.
People lie. People will hurt you. That is human nature.
Good things will happen. Wondrous things. Riches may land at your feet, or fame.
But Truth is something you must constantly seek. Your Truth. No matter how painful. No matter how uncomfortable it might make you sometimes. Know thyself, and you won't lose your way. Or even if you do, you will find your way back again.
I don't plan my blogs. Ever. I don't write them in Word and edit them and then paste them in here and press Publish.
I sit down. I write. And what comes out is my Truth.
I don't self-censor. I don't censor. Period.
I'm working on a memoir--part Mommy Memoir (from my adventures as a Pirate Queen with Pirate Boy), part spiritual quest in my journey through chronic illness. Part funny. Part poignant. All True. Over time, from my Pirate Boy Tweets and Facebook quotes, I've heard from at least a half-dozen editors and agents about it. The proposal is ready . . . and one thing I kept in mind while writing was advice from a wise agent. "Don't bother writing a memoir if you aren't going to be honest."
My guess is a couple of people won't be happy when they read it. Well, they should have conducted themselves a little more nicely. A lot of people, I think, will laugh and cry. But in the end, what ended up on the page was Truth.
I own mine. It's my most precious treasure. And it is my hope that those I love know theirs. That you know yours.
Thoughts?

18 comments:
Glenn constantly lied; it was like a thing he couldn't help. I also had a student who was quite literally a psychopathic liar.
The woman I, um, emailed you about last month in that event is lying, and I can't figure out why, except to just be mean. I guess that's gratification for some people? I don't understand. It sounds like this guy was doing something similar. But why do people go out of their way to cause grief for other people? I just don't understand that kind of meanness, when it's deliberate, and there's no reason for it except some kind of twisted self-gratification. I don't know.
Hi Natasha, hon . . .
The greatest gift I ever gave myself was to stop wondering why people do what they do--aside from wondering in a "writing my novel motivation" kind of thing. I can't FATHOM it. And it can be CHILLING, utterly chilling to run across it in real life, people for whom lies trip across their tongue.
And I tried to make clear, this was not GRAY. Not . . . "I walked away and heard x but he meant y." This was a bold statement with unhappy consequences, a statement of ugly bravado.
In the end, I do think that some people are sociopathic in their lying. They are people who tell themselves a "Truth"--their Truth--so MUCH and so often that they start to believe it. And then they grow comfortable with it until it shuts off their other moral barometers. Like men who beat women and think they are "asking for it," or the guy who hears "no," but goes on to commit date rape because he thinks there's a yes in there. And so I don't single out gender, women who can tell cutting lies about other women in order to feel more beautiful or what have you.
The wonderful thing about walking in Truth though is walking in the light. In being sure YOU know who you are and nothing can take that from you.
xoxoxox
E
Reading your blog I thought of Cloud Atlas - "Truth is singular. Its versions are mistruths" Somni 451. I feel like Forest Gump on this subject: I don't know who is right - Momma or Lieutenant Dan. Is truth absolute and singular or shaded and nuanced? If we admit grades of lying (from sociopathic to little white), do we not also admit shades of truth. Is there a truth - lie dichotomy or continuum? I am still mulling that one! However, even though I lie like rug, I try very hard to tell the truth...to speak the truth lovingly.
Some people are so adept at lying it becomes their truth. That's because they're not only lying to others but to themselves. It's to our benefit, though not always easy, to remember that the lies are about the liar. They may be meant to hurt us...but really have nothing to do with us at all.
Does that make any sense?
CML:
That's why I think there are two versions of truth. You know I don't lie. At least I sure as hell try not to, even when it's not CONVENIENT to tell the truth (hence, remember, I would not change my FB status that time). But the incident in question, where there a tape recorder, a hidden camera, would definitely have a truth. There is NO wiggle room.
But I do think some people twist their Truth to justify what they do while ABSOLUTELY and faithfully believing they didn't lie. Such people puzzle me.
And more to the point, I am truly weary of people trying to get me to release my Truth in favor of something more palatable. My Truth is my own and I hold to it. In fact, I am so grateful for its clarity. And speaking the truth lovingly . . . something I try to do as well. How beautifully put.
And by the way, we need to have coffee, Dude.
Amy Sue:
ABSOLUTELY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
One time, a woman called me and said the ugliest words a human being has ever said to me. In fact, even when I was going through my DIVORCE, my ex never said words like this woman. It went on a bit, just cursing and spewing ugliness. And one thing she said, which I took as an insult at the time, was that there was no way I was as nice as I pretended to be. And that I should get down on my knees and pray for how ugly I was inside. (Only she used a lot of expletives. Word choice: "F***ing B****.)
NOW . . . with hindsight, I realize it said so much more about her than me. Sorry, I AM that nice. Not perfect, but NICE. And so it was a reflection that she couldn't imagine someone being that nice. A lot more about her. Nothing much about me in there. Took me a while to realize it though.
Very freeing when I did. :-)
Wonderful outlook. You so often say things in the way I would mean them if I tried to say them.
I have people in my life who have different Truths. One is a control freak in a position of authority, and the other is subordinate to the control freak. It's so frustrating watching the authoritative one try to browbeat the subordinate into being different. Rather than trying to see it from the subordinate's perspective and trying to come to common ground. It is often difficult being the mediator, or, more frequently, the clean-up crew.
And yet, somehow I am graced and cursed with the ability to see it from both their sides.
Sigh.
Lies are quite often a reflection of the liar.
When I was getting divorced (strangely enough, E) someone said things to me far meaner than my ex ever did as well. She attacked my character and my motives and my life.
The more I thought about Somni 451's line (Truth is singular. It's versions are mistruths) the better the line became. The usage of mistruths is perfect. The line is not "it's versions are lies." Instead of lies we have mistruths. A mistruth is different than an out and out lie.
You write, "But I do think some people twist their Truth to justify what they do while ABSOLUTELY and faithfully believing they didn't lie. Such people puzzle me."
I can never decide on such people. If they absolutely and faithfully believe they are truthful, then they are not lying (at least from their POV). This is why I cannot embrace complete relativity in truth. If truth is not in some sense singular, there are no lies (and no truths, too)
I think the famous Supreme Court argument on another subject applies to lying: I know it when I see it. I can't exactly define it, but I know it when I see it. I certainly know it when I see it in me.
Agreed to coffee!
Peter:
Thanks, as always, for commenting.
I have been in those situations where people do not seem to find a Middle Way. It's draining to be in the cross-fire. :-(
Amy:
This had nothing to do with the divorce--but it was shocking to me that someone who was barely an acquaintance had more venom than my ex--who, like any people going through a divorce, had a lot more reasons to be angry.
And I think life is like the playground--or should be. You don't have to LIKE everyone. But you need to play nice with everyone. Unfortunately, I've met more than my share of people who can't even follow that simple rule.
Like you, perhaps, I am grownup enough to not need for everyone to like me. I know I am an acquired taste, as they say. I march to my own drummer. But my character and motives are what you see/what you get. I don't have the energy to be operating with deceit.
CML:
Wow . . . heavy thoughts for so early. I need my coffee.
I think I do agree with you. Though, I suppose . . . here I go . . . that perhaps I don't think people like that TOTALLY don't know they are lying or behaving badly. I think they KNOW, but they convince themselves it's for a greater purpose--which is different. But I have to wonder if DEEP down it does not trouble them. Just a hint.
You might be familiar with the lie I am speaking of. It was such a bold lie, so horrid. But I have to think he despised what I represented so much, he could justify his actions.
But yes, perhaps there is a singular Truth. For ME, it is BE KIND. For you, since I know you are a Christian (unlike myself), it is probably, "the Greatest Commandment" that Christ gave. What greater Truth could there be than that? Even I, who wants nothing to do with churches, can see that. It is a beautifully expressed Truth. So when people don't operate as such . . . they drift from Truth.
Good stuff. Great words from a friend I haven't talked with in a long time. Just a thought to throw a monkey wrench into things (sometimes that's what Truth does, I think)...what if the Truth sometimes seeks us out? We assume that in the game of hiding seek, we're the one that's "it," and we have to somehow find the hiding Truth. Sometimes I worry, though, that the Truth is stalking me, and the more I run from it, the closer it gets. Sometimes it even seems to sneak up on me. I've been t-boned by the Truth...at least that's what it seems like to me.
Ben:
All right. NOW we're getting WAY deep.
And I think yes, sometimes. My father is an avowed atheist. Who sometimes, in his sleep, composes GOSPEL songs. Songs never heard before. Make sense of THAT.
And sometimes, Truth, the capital T one, seems to find us--T-bone us, to use your expression. If you don't learn the lesson you need to, it keeps coming back until you do. Over and over. Until, at LAST, you "get it." Whatever "it" is.
In a spiritual sense, if you use Truth that way . . . then I tend to agree with you--when I am feeling of the mind that way. We seek, and seek, and seek, and lose our way, and sometimes the harder we seek, the more elusive Truth is. I know atheists who have WANTED faith, been jealous of it (or agnostics, who have been jealous of firm faith), and it simply does not come to them. Then, I presume, for some, an event happens when they do "get" it--maybe all the way to those "light down the tunnel" events of people who have had near-death experiences who come back and are completely changed.
For me, three years ago, give or take, what faith I had kicked my ass so badly, I can't even fathom to utter a prayer. But I do still seek Truth, if only in that "greatest commandment," which is one, it seems, any soul can agree with.
Ben:
P.S. . . . thank you so kindly for stopping by. :-) I keep up with your gorgeous family on Facebook and their smiling faces always bring me utter joy.
I sent you ecard for wishing a Happy New Year, but you haven't picked it up. You have still problems with your emails. I sent it to …@verizon.net
Thanks, FF . . . I'll see if it went in my SPAM folder.
HAPPY NEW YEAR TO YOU, TOO!
Post a Comment