Friday, March 13, 2009

The Path

Here's a great Buddhist quote that applies to writing. At the word "spiritual" in the first sentence, simply insert "writing."

"When we start out on a spiritual path we often have ideals we think we're supposed to live up to. We feel we're supposed to be better than we are in some way. But with this practice you take yourself completely as you are. Then ironically, taking in pain - breathing it in for yourself and all others in the same boat as you are - heightens your awareness of exactly where you're stuck."~Pema Chodron

I could take this quote in numerous ways. First, so much about writing is living up to some ideal--imagined or real. How many times have you had a scene in your head, written in, and wanted to pound your head against the keys because it just doesn't live up to what's inside your brain?

Second, roam cyberspace. There's lots of advice about what you are "supposed" to do. Heck, I post stuff like that all the time. You're "supposed" to ruthlessly rid your manuscript of back story, for example. But there's a difference between "we're all in this same boat of pain" and "I am the writing Buddha and therefore I have inherently more wisdom that you are--and you must obey me." Writers with that delusion are out there in the blogosphere. I stopped visiting one site because of a sense that it was never about the "boat." If you know anything about Buddhism, you also know that it would be impossible for Buddha to speak in such a manner. He even said that no matter what wisdom he imparted, it was all experiential. All teaching must be verified experientially by the student. When you get five rejections because you have too much back story, maybe then you'll believe me. I've even worked with writers and had to resist the very un-Buddhist quality of saying "I told you so" a few times when they got their rejections back. (Only because they were so stubborn.)

In the end, you have to write. Get in the boat. You can read about writing all you want. You can even blog about it. But you have to do it. A lot.

The other part of this quote is an acceptance element ("take yourself completely as you are"). I consider that portion of it, as it pertains to writing, as finding your voice. I write in a distinct way. I want to be a better writer in my distinct way--I don't want to write like someone else. My general voice, in my writing, is sardonic. Sarcastic. Wry. Snappy in the dialogue. When I stray too far from it . . . I generally flounder. As dark as it was, I thought parts of The Roofer were really funny. Uncle Two Times may have beat murder raps twice, but he also walked like a Weeble.

Acceptance as you are, though, doesn't mean you can't get better as you are (i.e., in your own voice). That's the boat we're all in together. That is our shared "pain."

Thoughts? Are you in the boat? On the path?

28 comments:

ssas 9:06 AM, March 13, 2009  

I've been thinking about this a lot lately, per my own posts about internal narrative. How much is right for me? I get conflicting messages about this from different quarters and so I constantly question.

But a wise friend recently told me, "It sounds to me as if you're finally finding your voice."

That helped. A LOT. So much of writing is about the journey--and I love that about it, too. But sighting the occasional expanse of shore from the crows nest gets me through.

Jude Hardin 9:34 AM, March 13, 2009  

Sometimes I feel like I'm out to sea in a wooden rowboat.

One that leaks.

And sharks are circling.

Wait a minute. I think there might be a story there...

Kath Calarco 9:54 AM, March 13, 2009  

I guess, as writers, we constantly second guess ourselves, or have personal "ideals" and then we blog hop for answers, which for me, at times, leads to further confusion.

I read all the "advice" posted in blogs on a "use what I can, can what I can't" basis. But still, more times than not, information in blogs makes me third and fourth guess myself.

Erica Orloff 10:55 AM, March 13, 2009  

Hi Sex Scenes:
I think that's awesome. I had lunch with an old professor of mine and he said, "If you could change anything about what you learned in college, what we could do better, what would it be?" I basically said something about helping the students learn their own voice. But I also know . . . it's definitely a journey.
E

Erica Orloff 10:56 AM, March 13, 2009  

Jude:
LOL! I'll be sure to toss you a life preserver. ;-)
E

Erica Orloff 10:57 AM, March 13, 2009  

kath:
For the most part, I hope my belief of . . . it's a journey comes through on this blog.

E

Kath Calarco 11:18 AM, March 13, 2009  

Erica, on your professor's question, and your answer,I'm with your answer with a big Hell YEAH!

One thing I'm seeing, and admiring, in my college travels is the "voices" of the other students, and the professors NOT mentioning it. Not that they have to, but I'm just saying, it'd be nice if a professor would comment about it from time to time.

Anonymous 11:21 AM, March 13, 2009  

Great quote for me today. My writing is often personally painful. It involves painful things and it brings up painful or sometimes angry feelings for people. Mental illness and child abuse are not easy things to write about.

I read books where it seems to me the authors have held the subject at bay. I want my writing to be more honest than that. It is all fiction, but I try to make it honest fiction. And that reveals a lot of the pain in me.

I guess the Buddha has it right. Only if we live in the full knowledge of our pain can we be whole and true to ourselves. Since our writing is another life act, that applies to our writing too.

Erica Orloff 11:37 AM, March 13, 2009  

kath:
I know when I was in college, I "tried on" a couple of voices. I had one exceedingly dark one. I thought that was my voice. I thought only standups wrote comedy. Then one day I found my comic voice and it hasn't shut up since.
E

Erica Orloff 11:38 AM, March 13, 2009  

Joe:
In that way, writing is a courageous act. I think most writers pour bits of their inner selves into their work,
E

Anonymous 12:56 PM, March 13, 2009  

I'm definitely in the boat too, and love your description of "shared pain". I'm definitely interested in the journey. And so true, I don't want to write like anyone else either. In life, the most beneficial thing for me was getting rid of internal stuff I no longer needed, or doesn't represent who I am now. Who needs the extra baggage?

As usual, great blog!

Erica Orloff 1:36 PM, March 13, 2009  

LaDonna:
Traveling light is definitely a good idea!

Melanie Hooyenga 2:26 PM, March 13, 2009  

I'm glad you mentioned that you've stopped reading blogs when the host acts like they're the authority on writing (my words). I only read blogs that have a community feel.

Earlier today on Spy's blog I said that I try to tune out the people who lay down laws and demand you follow them, no matter what. I've become friends with one of those people, I just try to dodge his "advice."

Spy Scribbler 2:42 PM, March 13, 2009  

Hah! I was just thinking about this sort of thing today. I swear I hadn't read your blog when I wrote mine. :-)

I loved Uncle Two Times! And I recently spent hours upon hours trying to convince a parent to try having her daughter do my assignment for ONE WEEK. But her mother was worried her daughter wasn't motivated, and couldn't put two and two together that the mother's methods were continuing to de-motivate her daughter. After about ten lengthy emails, she finally tried, and sent me a snotty email the first 3 nights telling me how badly it was going. But after one week, her daughter was happy and confident again. She hasn't talked to me since.

*sigh* I did not say "I told you so" but people never thank you for being right.

Erica Orloff 2:53 PM, March 13, 2009  

Hi Melanie:
I appreciaet this little writing community we've got.
E

Mark Terry 3:13 PM, March 13, 2009  

As you know, I'm reading "Zen Guitar." I'm also a student of the martial arts. I learned something right away in that book that after 4+ years of studying karate I didn't know.

He said that we in the US tend to translate "sensei" as "teacher," but that its literal translation is closer to "one who has gone before."

Which makes so much more sense when the senseis and masters in my particular karate style say they're not actually teaching, they're "sharing what they know."

I keep reminding myself that in my blog, particularly when I share particularly shitty stories--I've had more than my fair share of them in regards to fiction publishing--that I can only really teach what I've experienced. If you're one of those lucky bastards that wrote one novel and had it picked up for 6 figures and your career got off to an amazingly running start, what you share with me won't be all that helpful.

When I started out writing I kept drifting to those stories--the big advances, the movie deals, the "it's all gonna turn out fantastic because it did for me" stories. But over 20+ years of writing I've come to the conclusion that those stories, though inspiring, aren't necessary helpful and aren't necessarily typical. (They sure haven't been for me).

So take everything I say with a grain of salt, but keep in mind, it reflects my experience. Your mileage may vary.

Erica Orloff 3:18 PM, March 13, 2009  

Spy:
A well-placed "I told you so" would feel nice once in awhile. ;-)
E

Erica Orloff 3:25 PM, March 13, 2009  

Mark:
That's very illuminating . . . and definitely, all anyone can offer is their experience. I know the FIRST thing I say to writers who want me to edit their books is "I can't guarantee a sale, I can only make it better." I can bring MY experience but there are things no sensei could know.

Anonymous 3:53 PM, March 13, 2009  

I found the middle way. Thank you.

Erica Orloff 4:16 PM, March 13, 2009  

cowboy:
LOL! Welcome to the Path.
E

Spiced Apple Eye 7:06 PM, March 13, 2009  

Enjoying your conversation.

Amy Sue Nathan 7:10 PM, March 13, 2009  

I had to read the quote a few times to absorb it. That's a good thing.

I believe that as a person I got into the boat when I divorced, realized my true self and knew that the outside of me was merely a shelter for the inside. "Take it or leave it - this is the package I come in at the moment" (said with a smile, not a snip) became my motto for a single mom life.

As a writer, I don't think I've yet evolved to the place were I'm 100% sure of my truth - but I am in the boat. I do take all the writing wisdom with a grain of salt - but I do process it and realize that it is someone else's truth for sure, so it has value, at least to be considered. I try to be open to everything without allowing any of it to overwhelm me - because when that happens, I can't write - which defeats the purpose!

Erica Orloff 1:40 PM, March 14, 2009  

Hi Richmond:
Thanks!
E

Erica Orloff 1:41 PM, March 14, 2009  

Hi Amy:
I am really . . . I don't know . . . I guess happy with my age, with what I've learned along my path. Life is continually challenging and continually filled with growth.
E

Edie Ramer 10:26 AM, March 15, 2009  

I'm learning every time I write. I revised yesterday. One revised scene left me feeling blissful. The other one I had to pummel away at the words and sentences, drawing blood. It took me about five times longer to revise it than to write the orininal scene.

So sometimes I'm sailing along. Other times I'm looking for the lifeboat.

Sarah Laurenson 3:44 PM, March 15, 2009  

Awesome quote. Thank you!

Sorry I haven't been aorund much lately. Swamped more than usual.

Erica Orloff 8:24 AM, March 16, 2009  

Edie:
I love that image of you pummeling the words!

Erica Orloff 8:24 AM, March 16, 2009  

Hi Sarah:
We miss you! Thanks for dropping by!!!

xo
E


  © Blogger template Brooklyn by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP