Tuesday, November 09, 2010

Don't Let Go

I was watching Law & Order and knitting two nights ago, and it was one of my repeats I love with Detective Munch (SVU). I have been a fan of Richard Belzer since he was in NY radio way back when. Anyway, at the end of the episode, he is shouting at his captain that he KNOWS the woman they let get away with murder, indeed got away with murder, because of her wealth and her family's power. And for the captain, it would just be better if this whole "thing" went away. But Munch isn't wired that way. He can't let go.

In real life, my Russian relatives have been known to carry grudges for over 60 years. They're definitely the "I'll spit on your grave" type. My dad is the "I'll spit on your grave type." Though he would usually use another way of expressing it, and I'll just leave it at that.

In the last year, I went through something where everyone around me just wanted me to move on from something. But for me, it was not about carrying a grudge at all. (I don't.) It was about what is RIGHT. Standing up for truth. And for that, I'm one of those people that even if it costs me dearly (and in this case it did), I don't care. I hold my head high--in fact, if I am being honest, indeed I look down at the people who opted for political expediency over doing the right thing. I can't imagine living your life without a backbone--or being so weak-willed that if someone talks nastier and uglier, you'd rather hide in their shadow than speak up. And damn if I am not happy my father raised me with tenacity.

It's tenacity, at this point, that has me even WALKING based on my auto-immune disorder's recent showing.

But spin it into fiction.

Moby Dick would not exist if they decided to go home and put the ship in drydock.

Not letting go of the truth, of what is right, no matter the cost, is the stuff of nearly every thriller or detective story I can think of. If the detective/cop, etc. was not "thisclose" to be killed over a secret, there wouldn't be that much of a storyline.

But this guy and I have discussed it, because at SOME point, there can reach a line of demarcation where believability is stretched and most people would walk away. MOST PEOPLE. I think the way to make it believable isn't the level of risk . . . it's the back story of the character. It's planting enough there to make you believe, totally, that even if it means death, or losing everything, THIS character is going to see it through to the end.

In ILLUMINATED, my 2011 Penguin release, it's a YA romance. And at some point, the situation my character finds herself in means risking not her life, but her relationships with the adults in her life. I.e., "getting into BIG trouble." Now there are teens hardwired to not care if they get in trouble, but the teen in the story isn't one of them. She is the class valedictorian, a virgin, doesn't drink, doesn't do drugs. She's a brain. But as she researches the illuminated manuscript, she comes to believe--as only the romantic and the dreamers can--that somehow the fates NEED her to uncover the story, and that somehow, this will bring her closer to understanding her own mother. I think the motivation is clearer this time around . . . .

So think about it. What character have you created that "won't let go" even when it makes perfect sense TO let go? Tell us about it!

16 comments:

Mark Terry 9:06 AM, November 09, 2010  

That's pretty much Derek Stillwater's defining trait.

Erica Orloff 9:23 AM, November 09, 2010  

Mark:
It was so funny, but when I saw Detective Munch screaming after Captain Cragan, I thought, "There you go. Every cop or thriller book in existence--they all have this trait."

Merry Monteleone 9:53 AM, November 09, 2010  

I think it's universal in a great character... most people wouldn't risk that much, go that far, dig that deep... but we don't want to read about most people, we want to spend our time with the extraordinary, in hopes that we can someday BE that, even if on some level we fear we don't have it in us...

btw, E, I dig your dad more all the time :-)

Erica Orloff 10:11 AM, November 09, 2010  

Merry:
LOL! I am pretty positive he would dig you, too. :-)

ssas 10:37 AM, November 09, 2010  

Trinidad can't let go of the Bishop's lie. As a kid he turned his back on his whole life, his coven, his faith, even the truth, for the sake of Christ and his priest. When he realizes he's the only one who knows the truth and that it will cost him everything to prove it, he still can't let it go. He's driven to make it right, not only to spare the people war, but to prove to himself that he made the right decision in his faith, that Christ is the best example, even if the church is not.

Trinidad has a lot wrong with him, but that, at least, is right.

And Castile? He can't let go of his faith and love for Trinidad, even though life would be SO much easier if he did.

Erica Orloff 12:14 PM, November 09, 2010  

Starbucks:
That's a great variation on the can't-let-go . . . when it's righting an earlier wrong.

Spy Scribbler 1:08 PM, November 09, 2010  

You know, people misuse the word "grudge." I mean, there's a 60+ year old playground bully here, and she caused all sorts of drama last year and ticked me (and many others) off.

I've forgiven her. I wish her well. In fact, I make a point of sending her a well-wish every night.

I'm just not going to talk to her or be around her or act friendly to her. I'll avoid her if I can. I will not make myself vulnerable to her again. It's really not a grudge: I don't feel "ill will" or "resentment" towards her. She's just been ejected from my life. That sounds cold, but... I can forgive a lot. I feel sorry for her. But no.

Erica Orloff 1:39 PM, November 09, 2010  

Natasha:
I have tried to explain that difference to more people than I can count.

Andrew Vachss, years ago, was on Oprah as one of her "heroes." He told her she was a wonderful person and a beacon for survivors of incest and child abuse, but she did a disservice to ALL of them by INSISTING that "forgiveness" was a part of the "closure" equation. That's just so much bullshit.

I have forgiven MANY people in my life for various things from small to large (just as I have asked forgiveness for many things from small to large). But in some cases, it means I have moved on, but you are right, it doesn't mean I extend open arms to them in any fashion. I will likely be a cold-hearted b-word to several folks until the day I die. And I am OK with that . . . But it doesn't mean they are baggage in my existence. They just don't exist to me.

As I told my Significant Other about a client who screwed me, "He's dead to me." The Russian in me . . . well, I mean that. I waste no energy remaining MAD. It's just . . . he's dead to me. And I feel that way about my former church. It is dead to me. The few people I remain friends with from there, I will love to the end of time. The institution? Dead.

Makes life more manageable. I only have but so much room for drama in my life.

Nadine 6:39 PM, November 09, 2010  

My husband says I hold onto things for too long and that I hold too many grudges. (he forgives really easily). But the thing is, just because I'm not ready to forgive, does not mean I'm holding on to them in a way that is affecting my life.

I've been kicked, pushed, bullied, excluded and teased for a lot of my life (I was the shy easy target) and even though I've moved on, I don't forgive. I also don't choose to think about any of them, wasting my time or energy.

When several of the kids from jr. high (who made my life hell) tried to friend me on Facebook recently, I took great delight in clicking ignore. I don't forgive them but I don't wish them harm, I just don't want them in my life. At all.

Nadine 6:49 PM, November 09, 2010  

Sorry, I didn't relate it to my fiction. My MC refuses to give up on the mystery, even though she's risking everything including her sanity. But solving the mystery is that important to her.

Spy Scribbler 7:12 PM, November 09, 2010  

Exactly! I mean, how ridiculous is it that people think that if you don't become friends and make up with the person, that you're holding a grudge? Why SHOULD you become friends with them? That's just stupid. What is that quote? First time, shame on you; second time, shame on me.

Melanie Hooyenga 8:29 PM, November 09, 2010  

I had a comment, then I read the comments and I have to reply to that first. I'm finally at the point in my life where I can exclude people from my life and not waste any energy on them. It IS a big difference from holding a grudge -- they don't get space in my head.

As for my writing, I'm SO excited to finally be able to say yes, my character has something she'll risk her life for. I can't tell you HOW yet, but it's exciting. :)

L.C. Gant 11:40 PM, November 09, 2010  

Fascinating post. I was particularly moved by Nadine's comments on it.

Like her, I was the shy, easy target who was bullied and picked on as a child, too. I could deeply relate to her feelings toward the people who made her life miserable in junior high.

At the same time, I think folks can be too quick to cut others out of their lives. I believe in giving people second chances, especially if it's clear that they regret their mistakes.

I've had friends who cut me out of their lives even after I admitted my mistakes and tried to change. I felt condemned by that, and it was very painful. I don't think I deserved it.

Don't get me wrong: Some relationships are too toxic to be healthy and must be ended. But I wish more people would at least TRY to reconcile with those who hurt them before calling it quits.

Erica Orloff 7:14 AM, November 10, 2010  

Nadine:
Are you a Gleek? They did a great job last night with bullying, I thought. VERY poignant.

Erica Orloff 7:14 AM, November 10, 2010  

Melanie:
That IS a great turning point in fiction.

Erica Orloff 7:17 AM, November 10, 2010  

L.C.:
Great point. On the FLIP Side, I have OFTEN said I would never want to be judged in my entirety over the mistakes I made when I was 20 or 25, or 15, or whatever. The topic is too complex (on a personal or fiction level, I suppose) for comments thread. There are so many factors at play. I've been divorced . . . I frankly know my ex-husband is NOT the person who did x or y during that time, even though one or two thing she did will haunt me forever. And I know that I am not the person who did x or y as I was going through it either. You make your peace and move on.


  © Blogger template Brooklyn by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP