The Big Questions
It's an unusual thing to have four children span from adulthood down to Pirate Boy. Each of the four of them was raised when my my life was different, my health was different, my religion was different, my worldview was different. It's as if they have each had a different mother because their ages are so disparate. I have changed with each of them. That is the way of life and motherhood.
Pirate Boy is at the BIG question stage. I consider myself an optimistic person, content . . . in love with motherhood (mostly), and life (mostly). But I find my worldview has changed--and is still changing. So the "certainhood" that I might like to answer with as a parent is less so right now. I don't know that I have the answer to his BIG questions. But he seems content with my long-winded and not-so-sure answers.
Two days ago in the car (why does he always have BIG questions in the car?). "Mom, how come we don't go to church anymore?" (He hasn't been in a year and a half.)
"Do you WANT to go to church?" (Way to dodge the question, Erica.)
"Yeah. So how come we don't?'
"Mommy doesn't believe in organized religion." (Will that satisfy him? Um . . . no.)
"Why not?"
"Well, remember how we used to go to a happy church? Eventually it was ruined by in-fighting, unkindness, and hypocrisy. And I think it's hard to sustain goodness for too long in this world. Maybe it's the way certain people are wired."
"Well, can't you find a church that IS a happy place?"
"Is it important to you?"
"Yes."
"Is it because you like the cookies there? Or what?"
"I just like it."
Well, crap. "In my heart of hearts, I don't know that I can do that, even for you. Which says a lot about how hard that would be for me. But let me think about it. I would rather see you put your faith in the God of YOUR understanding than in people."
See what I mean? Big questions. Or his frequent . . .
"When will you die?"
"I don't know."
"Soon?"
"I hope not."
"Where will you go when you die?"
"I want to be cremated."
"What's that?"
"I don't want to be buried. I would rather have my ashes scattered at sea."
"Yeah, but after that? Heaven?"
What do I say? "If there is one, I like to think that I will be watching over you forever. Because I love you that much. I love you so much it feels like my heart expands and then breaks in two when I think of you. And that kind of love is something that survives even death."
Big questions. I thought that last answer was rather clever. Avoids it while appearing as if I am ACTUALLY answering him.
So then it was bedtime and he wanted the Itsy-Bitsy Spider book. He looks up at me and asks, "Is this a true story or a work of fiction?" (Swear he asked that--as with all his conversations I recount here or on Facebook, I'm just his transcriber.)
And that got me thinking.
We're all on this quest for answers to our big questions, and something about certain books unites us with other people looking for the same thing. I mean, there are beach reads and escapism. And that's terrific. But there are those pieces of fiction that somehow don't answer the big questions but perhaps let us feel less lonely for asking them. I still will never forget weeping over The Joy Luck Club. All right, MAYBE it was because I was 9 months + one week pregnant with my now six-foot-two son, and MAYBE my hormones were all over the place. And MAYBE I just wanted to go into labor and deliver my nearly nine-pound-baby. But if ever there was a book about motherhood and what it means--the sacrifice, the hopes and dreams of it all, the complexity of it, it is that book. For me. And since it was a massive best-seller, I think it was one of those works of fiction that transcends just my singular reading into a shared experience.
So as I choose books for Pirate Boy, I find myself wondering. What do I have to share with him? What do the books I choose for us to share mean? BEYOND Itsy-Bitsy Spider.
I suppose this is why I think books are important. Even if, like me, they don't have the answers to the BIG questions, they are a reminder that we are all asking them. I think back to my childhood books. Little Women. Jo's Boys. I think to the middle grade and YA fiction that somehow TRANSCENDED my reading them alone into something bigger. It is like, even today, when I find someone who has read and loved a book I have read and loved. There is that moment of excitement--we have SHARED something--even if we never knew it at the time.
Thoughts? What books have had the most meaning to you? Which ones have you SPECIALLY chosen to share with your children?
