Sunday, January 09, 2011

Tall Windows

I no longer worship in any traditional sense, nor do I anticipate ever worshipping in a church again, but there was a time when I went to a church and one of its most wonderful architectural details was tall, clear windows above the altar. For me, I would sit in spring and look at the shoots of leaves, and sit in summer and stare at the lushness of the season. I would sit in fall and admire the breathtaking colorful beauty of autumn, and I would sit in winter and be humbled by the stark gracefulness of bare branches. Mostly, I would sit and be aware I was in the presence of Something Greater Than I Am.

In the course of attending this house of worship, I started a food pantry, drove hundreds of pounds of food to the food bank, helped someone I love through the tragedy of losing a child, taught ESL classes, and generally busied myself being part of Something Greater Than I Am. In May of last year, I got a disturbing phone call from someone from that house of worship telling me I should "get down on my f***ing knees and pray for what a b****" I was." She told me I was loathed, "hated," and surrounded by "minions." It was a frightening call full of vitriol. In July of last year while the church was still in a state of turmoil over truly petty things, my Significant Other took my kids to a small church party--and returned home with my van keyed from one end to the other--truly gouged. I can't prove who did it. Of course, I think I know. But regardless, I knew whoever did had a lot of ugliness spilling from them.

Shortly after that, I received another call. This time telling me the leadership of that church, including the Man in the Collar, were, in essence, asking me never to reference church on this blog or mention the abusive call I'd received. I could ATTEND their church of tall windows, but I could not lead--which meant my ESL classes, and numerous other programs would no longer be things I could do unless I found someone new to lead them and I merely helped or assisted. Apparently, a blog I wrote offended someone there. Rather than self-censor my morning thoughts on writing, motherhood, spirituality, my children, life, and themes, I opted to leave this place of worship. What I found myself longing for, though, even aching for, were those tall windows, and the seasonal reminder of Something Bigger Than I Am.

But over time, I wondered. Were there more mean people in the world than kind people? Or was it simply that those who relished cursing and keying cars, or making scenes simply . . . were LOUDER and more out of control, so we noticed them more?

For months I pondered this. Thematically, in the themes of good versus evil, I wrote about it in fiction. And still I wondered. And still I longed for the tall windows.

After a while, I came to a new conclusion. That the people who think it's okay to curse at people were NOT more in number than the kind people. But that all of the people who stood around and said, "We feel bad that this happened to you, but . . . what can we do?" were more populous. They were, silently perhaps, tacitly saying "it's okay." I myself, I think, sometimes fell into that category. Because ever since I came to study spiritual figures like Buddha, and Ghandi, and Jesus Christ, "nonviolence" and turning the other cheek, and compassion were such deep-rooted themes, and conflict so against those ideals, that I often was silent in places where I felt outnumbered, or where I felt silence was the more graceful way. Oldest Daughter once even said, "I liked when you didn't study Buddhism because then you were in touch with your inner b****"--which admittedly can come in HANDY when fighting against bureaucracy or some other of the thousands of little battles we can find ourselves in during our lives.

And still, I missed the tall windows. I stopped feeling there was anything Bigger Than Myself because whoever that was . . . Bigger Than was silent, too.

And then I realized there was a reason for the silence. Bigger Than, if he/she existed, really expected the people with a conscience to do more than shrug and say, "We're sorry but . . ." I think Bigger Than expected that people of conscience would speak up.

So now I have watched the horrific news on the shooting in Arizona. And whether it's mental illness at the root of it, whatever it is as the story unfolds, there is a sense that we have allowed the loudest, ugliest of voices to talk about hit lists, and locking and reloading, and that people--whatever their politics, who have their disagreements but disagree in quiet ways--have allowed the Loud Ones free reign. It's not just politics and talking heads. I see it in grocery stores, in restaurants, even in a church with tall windows. Those who speak the ugliest of language are the ones we appease, we step aside for.

It's somehow my hope--I don't pray anymore--but somehow my hope, that if there is something Bigger Than I Am, Bigger Than ALL of US, that people can learn to disagree with civility.

I am also ever and ever more aware that words are weapons. I've been trying, this year, to choose my words wisely.
So for today I say . . .

Shalom.
Namaste.
Peace.
Love.
Compassion.
Kindness.

And remember, that sometimes silence is a good thing. But sometimes silence is cowardice. And may we all learn to discern the difference.

Thoughts?

[NOTE: I posted this last night and then pulled it. In some weird coincidence, my friend Natasha Fondren read it in the half hour in the night it was up and asked me where I went. I told her I didn't want to contribute to ugliness . . . only ask for tolerance. So my hope is it's taken in that spirit. Thanks, Natasha, for asking me to post it.]

42 comments:

Joe Barone 5:32 PM, January 09, 2011  

Wow! This post was truly powerful and filled with truth.

Those people you cited (Jesus, Ghandi, etc.) all stood strongly and publicly for justice. Many died for where they stood. The great blesssing of them all is that they found a way to speak in a non-violent way. Not a peaceful way always. But a non-violent way in which they spoke up, did not remain silent.

I pray that I might be the same kind of person. And I see you as that kind of person.

I am glad you decided to repost this so I and others could read it.

ps. The horrible rheortic and the violent images and words on the web did contribute to this violence. I am convinced they did.

Erica Orloff 5:45 PM, January 09, 2011  

Joe
I was afraid to post it. But being afraid is zero excuse for silence.
Thanks for commenting....

Mark Terry 7:02 PM, January 09, 2011  

"From time to time
The clouds give rest
To the moon beholders."--Basho

Heather Dearly 8:26 PM, January 09, 2011  

Well, this Catholic still loves you, no matter who you do or don't pray to.

Spy Scribbler 8:35 PM, January 09, 2011  

LOL, I wasn't up in the night... the RSS feed delivered it to my Google Reader. :-) When I clicked through, there was no post, and I was disappointed because it was a good one!

People are using this as a message to tone down the hate speech. We need something to temper the hatred in our culture right now. I know everything's cyclical, but things have been getting so prejudiced and full of hate, that I've been afraid of how far it's going to go before it stops. It honestly would be one blessing to find in the tragedy if this act helped turn the tide.

Being Beth 8:54 PM, January 09, 2011  

Personally, I think God has opened the tall windows and invited you out where you can live in the middle of Something Greater Than Yourself. I think he/she has opened a place for you where you can more freely expand your purpose and put a good sized dent in the universe. A dent that can't be tainted by those who are still held captive in their fortress church building and hypocrisy and who never noticed the tall windows or the Something Greater.

In time you'll find you are able to bear the cost of the words, actions, and anger of the people who hurt you in love and gentleness and compassion. And then one day I think you'll see once again that there is in fact that Something Greater Than We Are you long for, but you won't have to view it through the confines of windows, you'll see the whole.

At least that has been my experience after going through a very similar experience. Namaste, my friend.

Erica Orloff 8:58 PM, January 09, 2011  

Mark
love that!

Erica Orloff 8:58 PM, January 09, 2011  

Heather
xoxoxo

Erica Orloff 9:00 PM, January 09, 2011  

Natasha
I hate conflict. Passionate beliefs are good .... But we need doses of compassion.

Erica Orloff 9:02 PM, January 09, 2011  

Beth
I wish I could hug you!!!!

Cheryl Kauffman 9:14 PM, January 09, 2011  

Whoever did that to you is not a Christian. I loved this post. I agree sometimes silence is cowardice. I have had to speak up many times to advocate for my daughter. I used to be silent with her school but then realized I had to advocate for her.

Erica Orloff 11:23 PM, January 09, 2011  

Cheryl:
All kids need advocates, and kids who are different in any way need it even more.

Thanks for commenting!

Hugs,
E

PJD 1:02 AM, January 10, 2011  

Hurray to Natasha! This is a post that needed to be honored with an audience. Beautifully written, and I echo other commenters. (Beth, your comment is also filled with beauty and truth.) Thank you so much for sharing this. I have many thoughts, but essentially they all amount to "Amen, sister."

The one I will share is this: Two years ago I was fortunate to hear Bishop Desmond Tutu speak at a national United Way conference. I don't remember most of what he said, but one thing struck me. At one point he said that God wants us all to be happy, but He can not do it alone. If we could hear God, he would be saying, "Help me. Help me."

And now that I've quoted (paraphrased) Bishop Tutu, I'll quote Erica Orloff: Bigger Than, if he/she existed, really expected the people with a conscience to do more than shrug and say, "We're sorry but . . ." I think Bigger Than expected that people of conscience would speak up.

Erica Orloff 7:26 AM, January 10, 2011  

Peter:
To be quoted even in close proximity is . . . well, . . . . amazing.

And now I will remember that "Help me, Help me . . ." Very powerful.

Thanks . . . .

Amy Sue Nathan 7:31 AM, January 10, 2011  

I also read it yesterday, E, and just assumed you wanted to edit or tweak or had planned it for Monday.

A prevalent theme in Jewish teaching of the Holocaust is to tell how so many of Hitler's henchmen said (after the fact) that they "were just following orders." Many stood by the sidelines (many did not) and did and said nothing, realistically, in fear for their own lives.

Doing nothing does something. Often it says more than saying anything at all.

I'm sorry that your previous place with tall windows failed you. That one person's hatred infiltrated an entire congregation. Fear mixed with ego is a dangerous combination.

You can find your peace, help others, pray or not, anywhere at any time. This person or persons will never know real goodness - and because my inner Beyatch is alive and well, I'm glad. ;-)

((hugs))

Erica Orloff 8:15 AM, January 10, 2011  

Hi Amy:

On a personal level, you know, the two people primarily responsible for my leaving . . . I was completely non-shocked by what they did, what they said. I was STUNNED that people could have so much festering ugliness inside . . . but was I shocked? Not really. But I lost respect for all the people who said nothing, and it took me all these months to realize the disappointment in silent human beings was at the root of my sadness. I generally don't blog about things until I've figured out what it is I have learned from the life lesson, and now that I have, while I still do not pray . . . I do feel better. Ah-ha . . . in the words of Maslow, LOL! Ah-ha . . . THAT'S what really bothered me. Not the mean people. I knew then for what they were. It was the SILENT ones.
Now that's resolved in my mind, now that I have shed them all from my life . . . I feel free.

On a broader level, when I see events in the news . . . and when I see just hateful things (like the "birther" shouter from the congressional gallery) . . . when I see such a lack of human decency in how people talk about each other, talk TO each other, yes, it is easy to see parallels to horrible times past. My grandmother left Russia during the Russian revolution. Some of the stories of traitors and executions in the public square, the sheer madness of it all . . . yes, it is easy to see America has lost her way.

Richard Levangie 8:42 AM, January 10, 2011  

I'm sure that everyone knows the Edmund Burke quote: "All that is necessary for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing."

It really is time for Americans to take back their country, to restore honor, courtesy and respect to public discourse.

Love you, E, and love this post.

Erica Orloff 9:58 AM, January 10, 2011  

Hi Richard:

Love you, too!

You know, sometimes problems can seem so vast. The idea that a Buddhist monk, like Thich Nhat Hanh would say something as simple as "smile" seems absurd sometimes. But I tend to think differently. Be silent in small things like this incident in my life, and then silent on another . . . and another. Until good people are so silent that they lose the "muscle" of speaking up.

E

Stephen Parrish 11:09 AM, January 10, 2011  

I too read it when you first put it up (but didn't know until it came through my feed again that you'd taken it down).

Your passionate posts are my favorites. Wait a second: you don't write any that aren't passionate!

Erica Orloff 11:13 AM, January 10, 2011  

Steve:
Thanks. :-) I really didn't want to invite negativity . . . I really just notice that too many of us are silent.

Nadine 12:57 PM, January 10, 2011  

Evil people and hatred have always surprised me, especially since I am someone who goes out of my way to treat everyone with respect and kindness (even when they don't deserve it).

I avoid conflict like the plague but I'm fiercely loyal to my friends (and sometimes even strangers). If someone crosses them, I stand up and fight.

But not with fists - with words. Words are a powerful tool.

And Erica, if I lived near you and went to your church, I would've had your back.

Erica Orloff 12:59 PM, January 10, 2011  

Nadine:

:-)

I was raised that family and friends have your back. It often surprises me--not mean people as much as those for whom taking a stand is just not part of them.

Anonymous 1:47 PM, January 10, 2011  

Great Post as always! It seems to be a world wide phenomenon... Even here, I have seen people who sing the Lord's praises in churches and promise to strive to "follow Him", but the second it is time to leave, they curse and harm their fellow man. Completely contradicting their "beliefs". I am a Christian, but it does baffle me how many so called Christians seem to forget the essentials of what it means to be a Christian. It takes a whole lot more than hours spent in a building singing and praying to understand that there is a force greater than all of us out there.

Erica Orloff 1:58 PM, January 10, 2011  

Marcio:
I'm a mixed-bag of beliefs. But I can tell you, I try to be nice to all . . . and really wonder about some church-goers for the same reason. People are imperfect, of course. But some people just do not GET it. I'm with the Dalai Lama. My religion is kindness.

Barbara 4:26 PM, January 10, 2011  

I, too, miss the tall windows, my friend :) More than those windows, though, I miss the people that we all were then - the community. Something happened to the community and it turned weak and, honestly, just sad. Recently we were back in that place that meant so much to me and all I could feel was such a deep sorrow and sense of loss. I am confused by my responsibilities to God and people now - and feel the loss of that community as if it were a limb. Despite the sad and pathetic actions of the members, I still want that feeling back so, so bad ... I still pray for the chance to get it back somewhere - and if I am every lucky enough to, I will be bleeding before I let another community fall apart again! Love you so, so much! BB

Erica Orloff 4:54 PM, January 10, 2011  

BB:
Love you. Truly and deeply.

xoxoxo

ssas 7:15 PM, January 10, 2011  

I'm sad this one person and a few others turned you off church forever, especially when you'd found such joy there. But I know you'll be okay, cuz that's the kind of person you are. You are DETERMINED to be great and kind, and so you are.

:)

Melanie Hooyenga 8:14 PM, January 10, 2011  

I'm so glad you left posted this. I've also made a pact with myself to speak up more often when it needs to be done. Right now it's my boss who keeps making fun of heavy people. She's made several comments about someone being 'fat', then insinuating that that person can't do a good job or where fashionable clothes or be a qualified person because they're overweight. I've remained silent because I don't want to jeopardize my job, but I decided a) she can't fire me for telling her to stop talking about people that way, adn b) telling her that is better than punching her in the face. :)

Erica Orloff 11:46 PM, January 10, 2011  

Starbucks:
I found joy in service to the poor.

And to be honest, I was a narrow fit. I saw things that didn't fit with my worldview, but I was OK with it as long as they gave me a classroom to teach. :-)

Erica Orloff 11:50 PM, January 10, 2011  

Melanie:
That sickens me.

True story (and I blogged on this, ages ago before I knew you, I think) . . . when I first got very sick from Crohn's, they call my parents to come to my bedside to say goodbye so I could die. I pulled through. Then they put me on 160 mgs of injected prednisone a day, plus tons of other meds. In three weeks, I gained 60 pounds. And I discovered just how pathetic people's perceptions of appearance were. FAT is the last acceptable prejudice, sadly.

Aimlesswriter 6:19 AM, January 11, 2011  

Your post is inspiring. Thanks to Natasha for her encouragement.
We should all speak up but rememeber to speak positively.
This quote was from Nazi Germany and was first attributed to Pastor Martin Niemoller but it's real origin is uncertain.

They came first for the Communists and I didn't speak up because i wasn't a Communist.
They came next for the Trade Unionists and I didn't speak up because i wasn't a Trade Unionist.
They came again for the Jews and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a Jew.
And then they came for me and there was no one left to speak up.

Spiced Apple Eye 6:25 AM, January 11, 2011  

Some people don't care who they destroy along the way as long as they get their way. Free speech comes with responsibility and I don't remember ever reading any post of yours that I felt harmed someone else or denigrated the church.

Whoever reacted with so much hatred denied a lot of people in need someone who would act on her impulse and help another person in need. They didn't just harm you, they harmed the people you help.

I will add this, if we acted on every wrong we encountered, we would spend our days in endless battles without rest or success. Pick that which you are passionate about and can focus on and fight that fight. Let the rest go.

Erica Orloff 9:51 AM, January 11, 2011  

Aimless:
I love that quote--I've seen it morph over the years and applied to other events, but it's so powerful in its original.

Erica Orloff 9:55 AM, January 11, 2011  

Richmond:
I do think of that, at times. Most of what I did was not replaced. :-( Someone, meaning to be kind, said, "Oh, this event is your legacy" (they were still doing a Santa breakfast, which was something I had initiated and done for a couple of years and was my favorite thing). I was so unbelievably hurt and even angry by the comment. I should not have a "legacy"--I should be there doing it myself. That moment was when I realized it was all so toxic I needed to find new peace and also shed most of the people I met there. I do feel more at peace . . . and you are right. You choose your battles and let the rest fall away.

Kath Calarco 10:52 AM, January 11, 2011  

I've pondered the Arizona shootings, and have listened to those wanting to blame the lack of diagnosis to the lack of gun control. Still it seems what is lacking are those who want to mend our broken society. In my humble opinion, the fix begins at home, in our souls and conscious.

Tall Windows are inside you, Erica. Don't let the haters eclipse your wonderful view of life.

Erica Orloff 11:22 AM, January 11, 2011  

Kath:
There are many facets to the killings, of course. The lack of adequate mental health care in this country, gun culture, mental illness and its inexplicable course, sometimes. But I can't help but this the level of venom in our society is a piece of it. A piece.

And it took me a bit to get to where I am now--at peace. I don't need Tall Windows anymore. And I want to add that I don't want it to seem that the reason is anger. It's that I truly think Marx wasn't far off. It is a dangerous opiate when used incorrectly. I've come to see it as a sickness more than as something I want to be part of. Not in an angry sense but a philosophical one.

Joe Barone 12:19 PM, January 11, 2011  

Watch out for religious institutions. The people in them will get you almost every time.

I'm truly convinced we need to speak out (non-violently) about institutional evil most of all.

Kath Calarco 12:48 PM, January 11, 2011  

I've always concurred with Marx's theory. Why people need religion for their high is beyond me, especially when it gets out of control. History shows that many wars began out of religious misunderstandings and condemnation. What little the majority learns from past lessons, eh?

Melanie Hooyenga 9:32 PM, January 11, 2011  

Erica, I've seen predisone's effects on people and it's just awful. I think I've heard you refer to that time in your life, but not the specifics. That's so awful you had to experience that.

Erica Orloff 9:26 AM, January 12, 2011  

Joe:
I agree, I really do.

Erica Orloff 9:27 AM, January 12, 2011  

Kath:
I feel that way more and more.

Erica Orloff 9:28 AM, January 12, 2011  

Melanie:
At one point, I was on 160 mgs injected a day. I ended up with a steroid myopathy in which my sight deteriorated and I could no longer walk. It was awful. A horrible drug that, fortunately, also saved my life.


  © Blogger template Brooklyn by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP