Moments
You must live in the present, launch yourself on every wave,
find your eternity in each moment.
~Henry David Thoreau
Not only is this a great quote for how to live your life, but for how to write dialogue.
Last night, Oldest Daughter wanted help procrastinating. This basically means she comes in and flops on my king-size bed and insists on talking to me, even though I am clearly just a few deep breaths away from falling asleep. When I point out the obvious to her, she says, "No. Hang out with me." Note this was 11:00 p.m. Did I mention I rise at 5:30 a.m. and SHE is a night owl/musician?
Anyway, TV got flicked on and she breezed through channels, and all I got to see was ONE minute of the Movie Independence Day. But . . . it was a great moment of dialogue, in an otherwise popcorn flick.
In the scene, Jeff Goldblum (and can I tell you, I think he's sexy?) is riding his bike into the office--into the actual office, amongst the cubicles and so on. Riding bike must mean he takes his dedication to the environment seriously, folks. That's "movie speak" for "hippie." His assistant, played by my adored Harvey Fierstein, follows him around with that VOICE of his, telling him how the entire world is about to blow up or whatever. And in the midst of it, Jeff Goldblum notices someone didn't stick a can in the recycling bin. He makes a decent wisecrack, puts it in the bins, and the conversation keeps rolling without missing a beat. And on we go to find out that YES, MY GOD, aliens are about to eat us all alive, and YES, MY GOD, this brainy fellow is the one to save us all. But now, in the span of 30 seconds or so, we know his "type."
It was a moment. A non-writer wouldn't even notice. Hell, had I been SLEEPING and not forced to watch it, I wouldn't have noticed.
But the point is . . . so often when I am critiquing manuscripts (and right now I am doing the "contest judge" thing), I see HUGE back story dumps. If I was going to say what gets axed with my red pen more than anything else? Back story dumps. And writers hate parting with them. "But NOOOOOOOOOOO, I MUST tell the reader about his childhood on the banks of Lake Huron. It's important to the story later, on page 349."
Um. No.
Here's the thing, like our pal Thoreau, like the B-movie popcorn spectacle, look for MOMENTS. Drop the hint, move on. A line of dialogue could tell you more than an entire page of back story if done right.
I've used before as an example that I had to, in each book, tell the reader that Billie Quinn was a genius. It IS important, and while you might discern that after reading 300 pages, I, as author, don't have time for you all to get up to speed. I need you to know that early on. So it's her BEST FRIEND who tells us that. Billie, who narrates, tells the reader that Lewis LeBarge is a genius. She just flat out tells us he is the smartest man she's ever met, than most human beings will ever meet. He's the lab director, so even from a non-partisan viewpoint, he must not be dumb. And then at SOME point early on in the books, he says, in a throwaway line, something like, "Just because you're the ONLY human being who can keep up with my brain doesn't mean . . . " or "Shut up, I know your IQ is that high but it doesn't mean . . ." A moment of dialogue. I don't have to tell you her test scores, the scholarship she got, her academic background. None of it. A line. A moment.
Back to life. Find your eternity in a moment this weekend. I often find them in sticky kisses from Demon Baby. But wherever you find it . . . peace and joy, my friends.
Thoughts? What are your "eternity moments"? And how do you put in single moments in your writing?

22 comments:
Excellent post. Really excellent. Yes, like in my Derek Stillwater novels, it might be as simple as his boss, the Homeland Security Secretary saying, "Oh by the way, Derek, I'm not accepting your resignation. That's #14 this month, isn't it?"
As for eternity moments, aahhhh...
We played poker with my father-in-law on Sunday. My youngest son wanted to show him what the pros wear on TV to play poker, so he disappeared into his bedroom and came out with his hood up, wearing wrap-around sunglasses, and his iPod earbuds in. Ready to play. He'll be 10 next month.
It's those sorts of things that can be your eternity moments.
Hi Mark:
perfect example from your novel. I think it's the difference in my writing NOW versus say, 15 years ago, when I felt like I had to tell you all this back story up front. YAWN.
LOVE your poker story (as a poker player myself!). I have a lucky bathrobe. I also have a lucky porcelain antique urn to keep my change in. I am teaching my kids. My grandma taught me. Pass it on, you know. Pass on the eternity stuff.
She lives in them. That's what I tell myself.
E
I info dump on a rough draft, but when I go back I can usually review the dump to discover the moment. With practice, the moments are easier to find and the dumps in the drafts become smaller.
Heather:
Good for you . . . I know when I started losing my back story dumps, it was very much a new step in my writing, a very "ah-ha!" moment for me. :-)
E
My back stories are all separate chapters that are not even part of the WIP. Characters allude to pieces of the back stories in their dialog, but the back stories remain in a separate file…material for future books perhaps. I have enough of these separate back stories to build several books.
Hmm . . . JLK, what an interesting way to do it! I love hearing about others' processes.
E
Erica,
The way it usually happens is that I'll be working along on dialog and if I feel a back story coming on, I open a new document and get it recorded. That way I'm not tempted to include it in the main work. If, later on, I hit a mental block on the WIP, I'll revisit the back stories and flesh them out.
jlk:
Very neat technique.
I don't do a lot of backstory stuff on paper. HOWEVER, with this new trilogy, I have a story bible for continuity, and that has a LOT of backstory that may not even come into the books until the third one.
E
I must confess, my technique was not my idea, but that of the late great Lester Del Rey. When he reviewed my first submission way back in 1989, he slammed me for the heavy reliance on back story and in the process of "red-inking" the hell out my manuscript, suggested the "back story file". I was dubious of course, I needed those back stories afterall.
I think some sort of file, or story bible or something becomes more important with a series, because it is very easy in a larger work to "drift" and lose continuity between books.
In my wip, one of my character is empathizing with a co-worker who's unhappy because of her family did, and thinks something like "She knew what it was like to have a mother who never smiled when she looked at her."
I don't even mention that her mother is an alcoholic until much later in the book.
Absolutely. I get so frustrated when an author stops the story for twenty pages in order to tell me a character's biography. I DON'T CARE. Dialogue is a good way to approach it; action even better.
What we want to avoid, IMO, are lines of dialogue like, "Gee, Bob, I haven't seen you since we played baseball together in high school twenty years ago."
If you're going to use dialogue, it has to sound natural. If it sounds like an info dump, you've lost me.
Your examples with Billie are good, Erica; but, if we SEE her performing the way a genius would (as I'm sure we do, though I haven't read the books), I'm not convinced it's even necessary to include how brilliant she is in dialogue.
Well, Jude . . . I definitely hear you on all fronts.
As for Billie . . . you know, there's smart. And then there's genius. And ... it's a sharp distinction. And in her case, she's also incredibly streetsmart. And she has to "dumb down" her sciences sometimes for others. So . . . I usually just include the throwaway line.
And I love your dialogue example. I HATE when I find snips of dialogue like that. NO ONE talks that way.
E
Hi Edie:
Those are the things that are like peeling the layers back.
E
O.M.G.... I so needed to see this. Just had my 'aha' moment for my WIPs where they are not working.
Time for me to go rip and shred those sections (or at least make them a separate doc).
ewoh:
LOL! Run along and shred, my friend.
:-)
E
Hey Erica, I'm the odd one here I think. I enjoy backstory, not a dump but usually a flashback/dream route. I know, some people hate those. I wrote a mother-daughter story and it unfolded as parallel stories throughout. I loved writing the book, and think it worked. Should probably say the mama was dead, though.
My twelve-year-old character starts a conversation with a gravedigger she meets by saying, "Did you know that the weight of all the ants in the world is greater than the weight of all the mammals?"
This is the start of the book and the start of their friendship. I am hoping to convey that this girl is smart and can store all sorts of info in her brain but also that she is inept socially. She doesn't even say hello before spouting out this sentence.
As for eternal moments, the most powerful all concern my son. I have snapshots in time of my son doing something or just smiling at me that are as clear today as they were when they happened.
I think that's a brilliant line of dialogue to open with, Suzanne!
Thanks Jude. Each new chapter starts with her imparting a new weird and little known fact to the gravedigger.
This was terrific...
Today, I had an eternity moment. In the middle of rushing through my kid taxi run, I saw, *really* saw, the blue sky filtered through the bare tree branches, and I felt like I could breathe for the first time all week :)
Dialogue is the best place to reveal character...I do the same as Heather and find the huge infodumps on my first pass edit. If the info is important, I find the way to tuck it into dialogue, but it has to do double duty -- get the information across, and also reveal something important about the characters, the one conveying the information and the one receiving it.
This was a very cluttery, chore laden day...thanks for the cool thought to ponder as I rushed around!
MicheleL
suzanne:
I agree with Jude--it sounds great.
E
Michele:
I love those nature moments where . . . the universe seems to just give you a present like that.
And I love the way you put it--"double duty." The best of dialogue moves the plot forward. It tells us something. It's NOT conversation.
E
Post a Comment