Reading Aloud
I used to be in a large writers' group about 20 years ago, and because of its size, the policy was you signed up to read your work about once every other month or so, maybe once every three months. Reading aloud, besides terrifying me in front of such a large group, entailed being able to muster more than a monotone, in order that your work seemed to have some energy in terms of dialogue.
My next writers' group, as well as my current one, was small enough that we provided pages. Prior to the Internet being so widespread, we brought enough copies for everyone to read that night, and then provided comments. Now we email pages in the the 24 hours prior to meeting. I prefer this because the editor in me can spot word choices or grammar errors, or re-read certain sections. I provide much better critiques this way. I feel I receive better ones than the read-aloud way, too. It's also closer to what the manuscript will undergo in its submission process--real readers.
But I am slowly coming to the conclusion that all writers should read their entire work aloud at some point in the process.
In my life, odd as it may sound, I have never dated a reader. In fact, I seemed to have a propensity for attracting men who don't like to read, or in the case of my Significant Other, probably have significant learning disabilities (I am pretty sure he is dyslexic). But whether now, or in the past, I basically seemed to find people who hated to read. I considered that, for a long time, a blessing--I had MY life and all my writer friends. They had THEIRS. Now, not so much, since I really DO think it would be nice to discuss books once in a while. But that's neither here nor there. If, in the last 25 years, say, I wanted to share what I was working on with the men I dated or was involved with, it meant READING ALOUD.
So last night, I read two chapters aloud of my work-in-progress. He was impressed. I was less so. In the process of reading aloud, word repetitions jumped out at me and smacked me in the face. And considering the book has a more poetic cadence, is more literary, I heard the spots that needed more work. Considering too, that the book emphasizes hearing (sound is probably the most important sense in it and everything makes noise, the crunch of leaves, the ching of a chain on a biker, and the two-piston pop of a Harley), I heard when I missed, when the sound wasn't what I wanted it to be.
I read Spanish Disco aloud in galleys. I read Diary of a Blues Goddess aloud in galleys. It was because there was no way the man I was with would ever know what they were about unless I did so. And that was the LAST time I read any of my work aloud. Until last night. And now I'm thinking even if it's to myself, it's time to revive the tactic.
Anyone else read aloud? At what point in the process? And to yourself? Or someone else? Or the dog? I am contemplating reading to my dogs. I think they might like a nice story. There's also always the fish. But no way am I reading to Lydia. She's my son's python. I'm still afraid she might eat me.
Thoughts?

37 comments:
You and I really need to stop doing this.
I was just thinking yesterday, "You used to read all your fiction manuscripts out loud, but you haven't done that in a while. Maybe you should start up again."
Really.
I think it's good. I think you catch things you might not otherwise--repetitions, awkward phrasing. I'm of the mind that if you can't read it out loud without stumbling over it you should probably rewrite it. If dialogue isn't working, a lot of times you can catch it when you're reading out loud.
No, I really recommend it.
Mark:
Like minds . . .
And I think you're right--dialogue especially. I had two actors once read a short story of mine (I was considering making a one-act play of it--still may sometime) . . . and they injected nuances I hadn't even thought of and it definitely was eye-opening.
Also, this work I'm talking about is two different first-person voices--theyeach have to be distinct. One is a 17-year-old girl. One is . . . Death. So I'm talking REALLY distinct, and if that's not there . . . it's a useless exercise.
E
I think you should read to the mouse Lydia is about to consume. :)
I do read my work aloud sometimes. I've even read into a tape recorder to hear how it might sound as an audiobook. It's definitely a good revision tool, exposing phrases that trip you up, sentences that leave you out of breath, etc.
I can't imagine an author feeling confident in their work without having read it aloud at some point.
Currently I am writing rough draft material in a notebook. I never read that aloud or reread it or I would not be able to move forward. But once I transfer from page to screen I read everything aloud.
I've heard many an author say they read their work aloud just for that purpose, to catch mistakes.
Since I'm trying nanowrimo which is about output rather than quality (and learning I can't) I haven't tried reading aloud. I will when I begin the editing process because I have heard so many authors say how beneficial this is. Plus that backwoods twang is fun.
I'm married to a non-reader. He says he did enough of that in law school, but I say that maybe he should try reading something interesting. LOL
But, back when I was on a writing roll, I read my daily work to him. If nothing else, he's a great listener (when he has to be - after all, he IS a man). He'd hear the plot holes, and I'd see the bad dialog, etc. We made a great team. I now read to my monster chihuahua, but she's not so good at hearing plot holes unless they bark.
My dog is a great listener. Seriously. She (and I) participate in a literacy program for kids grades 1-5. The kids come to the local library and read to our dogs, who, of course, are non-judgmental listeners. I decided to try the same thing -- read to Cami -- not only to check for rhythm and repeated words, but to hear the narrator's voice. I can find places where I'm in and out of POV and where dialogue sounds artificial or forced. Reading aloud is only way I know to this. It's even better when someone reads your manuscript aloud to you. I never, ever read into a tape recorder because then I start critiquing the sound of my own voice.
Jude:
First, Lydian consumes rats. And I loathe rats more than snakes.
E
I read aloud very often, especially when I'm going over something that is so familiar to me that I'm not sure I'm actually "reading" it and not just reciting it in my head. Reading aloud, for me, means that things sound the way I want them to sound inside and outside my head, and hopefully that will translate to a reader. I also catch typos and grammatical errors and plain ol' stupid mistakes and wrong words, or, even better, I catch words that can be replaced with the perfect word.
I like it to be very, very quiet when I read aloud...and it also helps me get back into something i've set aside. Harder for my mind to wander when I'm reading and talking at the same time...although it is possible!
Heather:
WOW! See . . . I stopped doing that. And now I feel like, YES, I HAVE to. Why did I ever stop?
E
richmond:
LOL! I do sometimes try to affect a certain voice. No twangs, but in this wip, it's a world-weary voice.
E
kath:
I used to read aloud--books--to my ex-hudband, then current guy. And boyfriends along the way. But after a while, maybe being tired, having four kids, whatever, I stopped. Now, I just don't share. I think it's because I have writer friends, so I basically have that side of my personality covered with people who "get" me.
E
tena:
My grandmother had a very pronounced speech impediment (a whole Katherine Hepburn Parkinson's sound). My mom has it, and it's much less pronounced, but it is getting worse. And I inherited it too. I never used to "hear" it, but now I do find I can hear it sometimes, particularly on the phone if I am tired. It's not medically dangerous, just an inherited tremor. So I don't even bother with the tape recorder because I would hear every tremor now.
E
Amy:
The biggest thing I catch are word repetitions. I just HEAR them when for whatever reason I didn't SEE them.
E
Rats need love too.
I think you should at least send a little rat priest in to give the condemned his last rat rites.
I definitely read it out loud! My past two manuscripts, I've read the whole thing out loud near my last revision. You can especially notice the flow of dialogue when you read it out loud. If the dialogue doesn't flow naturally, it will definitely come across during a spoken reading. Sometimes I even act out certain scenes like the action ones to see if it's physically possible to strike someone with a knife or a stake or a fist as I had written it.
Jude:
LOL!
The whole "wild kingdom" aspect drives me nuts. I cannot be present or even home, if I can help it, when it's mealtime. As a Buddhist, the THOUGHT of feeding a live animal to a snake just sends me over the edge.
E
J.T.
I move my lips and whisper a lot when I write. I look like a crazy person. Um . . . AM a crazy person?
E
I read aloud, but not often enough. After awhile, my voice starts cracking. That's a family thing with me too. When my younger sister talks too much, she's croaking the next day.
I read everything aloud. The exception was when I was under deadline to an agent, but I read the first 75 or so to make sure the rhythm was right.
I also am about to read a short story aloud--an important one because voice figures very prominently.
And I know a fantasy author, who writes HUGE tomes, reads every word aloud. It's very valuable.
And my husband is not a reader either. He just tried to read my latest sci fi story and immediately got lost with the lingo.
And IHWM1--I love the idea of kids reading to dogs! I'm going to have my daughter read to my dog tonight!! (She is a great listener.)
jt,
Your "acting" reminds me of a funny story. A friend of mine "acted out" elaborate sex scenes with her kids' barbies in the basement and even used it in her pitch sessions at a conference.
The agents and editors loved it!
My internal ear reads aloud pretty well. It's just like looking at a sheet of music: I hear it all in my head. I do edit for awkward phrasing, often. If I have to change my inflection while reading in my head, then I edit the sentence.
I sat once in a critique group, and this one woman read my stuff out loud. I gotta tell you, she was so good, my stuff sounded amazing. It was totally deceiving, LOL.
edie:
Well . . . for anyone, reading 300 pages aloud can make your voice croak. :-)
E
sex scenes:
LOL on the Barbies.
E
spy:
When these two actors did mine, they added something I liked--and did something I DIDN'T like, so for the first time, I really "saw" and heard what a director brings to a play--all that interpretation of how to say a line, etc. And I saw how the right casting makes a huge difference. I still think of doing a one-act--in my "free" time. LOL!
E
Erica, you don't know how relieved you just made me feel. My husband isn't much of a reader, although he does read nonfiction here and there. The only way I've been able to share my writing with him is by reading it aloud, and he tunes out after half a page. I worried about this difference with us, but now I feel better. Thanks.
I definitely agree that reading out loud helps you catch the little nuances. I'm sure your dogs would LOVE to listen.
I read aloud when I get closer to the final draft. I've heard that if you read aloud too soon, you can mistake proper cadence for good writing. So writing on the page stuff needs fixed first, and cadence comes last.
So I do read aloud and record it into a tape recorder and listen to the playback.
My husband HATES being read to, but he'll read my stuff. He hates the business name I chose and the cover I chose, but at least he likes my writing, haha!
Hi Melanie:
I get tuned out after a half-page most of the time, too.
E
Zoe:
I used to be friends with an actor. He could make crap sound GREAT. So yeah, good point.
E
Erica, I think all authors have to be a little crazy. :P I mean ... we're constantly harassed by voices telling us—and in some instances ordering us—to write their story. Many people have been locked away for admitting to that. :)
Sex Scenes at Starbucks, (funny name BTW), that's hilarious. Gotta remember to break out the dolls next time. Though my husband might appreciate me practicing on him ... :)
I don't read any of my writing out loud any more. Maybe it is time to bring that back.
Back in the day when I wrote poetry and worked the slam scene I used to read aloud everything I wrote.
THe writers group was a lot like the one you talked about Erica - everyone brought copies and read along with the author - making notes along the way.
I don't read any of my writing out loud any more. Maybe it is time to bring that back.
Back in the day when I wrote poetry and worked the slam scene I used to read aloud everything I wrote.
THe writers group was a lot like the one you talked about Erica - everyone brought copies and read along with the author - making notes along the way.
ewoh:
The slam scene amazes me. You should blog about that some time!
E
I always read the WIP out loud. It helps me catch those mistakes that I've gone blind to.
In good weather I pace the deck with three dogs and a cat wandering around the yard. Either they don't like my work or they find the grass and trees more interesting. The dog pack has no comments and the cat just stares at me. I'm not sure there's a brain inside that little cat head.
In cold weather I pace around the house while the dog pack sleeps and the parrot keeps asking, "Is that good?" and I wonder what he means by that...
I prefer having someone else read it aloud. That way I get to hear where they trip up in the reading and that lets me know what sentences may not work. I also get to hear places where they read what they think is on the page instead of what's really there. This works well with a first time reading.
I am married to a reader but she reads adult literary and non fiction kind of stuff and I write for ADD kids. She will be my final reader on my new MS because she has such a different perspective.
aimless:
I am sure they love the work. :-) Just restless, you know?
E
Sarah:
I'm not sure if I could "take" someone else reading my work aloud. That seems so personal--like I'm not ready. I've had my books turned into audio . . . and it was SO difficult for me to hear a stranger read my words. I stopped listening after two minutes.
E
Post a Comment